This document provides a detailed overview of coding spanest practices, intended for reference and to serve as a convenient checklist during code reviews. Coding standards are continuously evolving, and this document is updated regularly as I discover new points to add.
1. Functionality
- Correctness: Confirm that the code operates as intended and satisfies the given requirements. Ensure that the logic implemented covers all specified scenarios accurately.
- Completeness: Check that all necessary features and functionalities are present. Ensure that no crucial elements or functionalities are overlooked.
- Edge Cases: Examine whether the code appropriately manages unusual and spanoundary conditions.
2. Performance
- Efficiency: Assess whether the chosen algorithms and data structures are optimal for the given problem. For example, instead of using a generic list, use a hash table for fast lookups and a priority queue for processing tasks.
- Bottlenecks: Check for any sections of the code that might be slowing down the overall execution. Pay special attention to database calls and other I/O operations.
- Unnecessary Repetitions: Look for loops or recurring processes that could be streamlined or optimized.
- Scalability: Consider how the code will perform as the data grows or under increased load. Look for opportunities for caching, parallelization, or asynchronous operations.
- Profiling Tools: Use profiling tools to identify performance bottlenecks in your code. These tools can help you see where your program spends most of its time or memory.
- Optimizing Hotspots: Focus on optimizing the most time-consuming parts of your code. Sometimes, small parts of the code are responsible for the majority of execution time.
- Cache Frequently Used Results: If certain operations are repeated with the same inputs, cache their results.
3. Reliability
- Robustness: Ensure the code can handle unexpected situations and inputs without crashing. Consider scenarios like empty inputs, extreme values, and invalid data.
- Consistency: Verify that the code consistently produces the correct results under the same conditions.
- Redundancy: Ensure that the code includes redundancy where needed, such as retries for critical operations.
4. Security
- Input Validation: Check that all user inputs are validated and sanitized to prevent vulnerabilities like SQL injection, XSS, and buffer overflows.
- Authentication and Authorization: Ensure proper authentication and authorization checks are in place to prevent unauthorized access.
- Data Protection: : Verify that sensitive data is handled securely, including proper encryption and secure storage practices.
5. Error Handling and Logging
- Error Handling: Ensure that errors are handled gracefully and that exceptions are caught appropriately. Look for informative and user-friendly error messages.
- Logging: Check for adequate logging of important events, errors, and exceptions. Logs should be clear, concise, and avoid exposing sensitive information.
- Debugging Information: Ensure that logs provide enough detail to help diagnose issues without overwhelming the log files.
6. Testing Coverage and Quality of Tests
- Test Coverage: Verify that there is adequate test coverage, including unit tests, integration tests, and end-to-end tests. Check that critical paths and edge cases are covered.
- Test Quality: Evaluate the quality of the tests themselves. Tests should be clear, focused, and reliable. They should cover both positive and negative scenarios.
7. Documentation
- Inline Comments: Comment on the intent and purpose of complex or non-obvious code.
- Code reflects intent: Use meaningful variables and method names to clearly convey the code's purpose
- Feature Documentation: Provide a summary of the feature’s architecture, outlining its major components and their interactions.
8. Code Structure, Readability, and Maintainability
- Code Organization: Assess whether the code is well-organized into modules, classes, and functions. Ensure that it follows the principles of modularity and separation of concerns.
- Deeply Nested Loops: Avoid deeply nested loops. Refactor nested loops by using functions or data structures that reduce the need for multiple levels of iteration.
- Break Down Complex Functions: Split large, complex functions into smaller, more manageable functions. Limit the length of functions to keep them manageable and easy to understand.
- Avoid Magic Numbers and Hardcoding: Replace magic numbers with named constants or enumerations. Externalize configuration settings instead of hardcoding them.
- Readability: Verify that the code is easy to read and understand. Look for meaningful variable and function names, consistent formatting, and appropriate use of whitespace.
- Duplicate Code: Practice DRY (Don't Repeat Yourself). Avoid code duplication by abstracting repeated patterns into reusable functions or modules. Refactor existing code when you identify opportunities for reuse.
- Commented-Out Code: Check for commented-out code and recommend its removal if it's no longer needed. Commented-out code can clutter the codebase and cause confusion.
9. Coding Standards
- Adherence to Style Guides: : Ensure that the code adheres to the project's coding style guide, including naming conventions, indentation, and formatting.
- Consistent Practices: : Check for consistency in how certain patterns and idioms are implemented throughout the codebase.
- Language-Specific Best Practices: Verify that the code follows best practices and conventions specific to the programming language being used.